I love a good story as much as the next person, and well I remember loving fairy tales (the scarier and bloodythirstier the better) as a child. My mother would read to my brother and I when we were young, and we loved this time and the wonder of it all.
But I didn’t know then what I know now – those stories are a psychological sucker-punch. They carry within them more material for false dreams and psychological meanderings, for hours spent no doubt on psychiatric couches, than their deceptively pretty covers suggest. They are a mental time bomb, a form of pre-programming for a life that is so unreal and un-life-like as to set us up for perpetual confusion and disappointment all down the years.
A writer, Colette Dowling, was really on to something in the 1980s when she published her book ‘The Cinderella Complex’. It chronicled the lives of women who put their own dreams and ambitions perpetually on hold while waiting for their prince to come. It very accurately showed that this fairy tale, so innocent in its deceptive guise, was really a proto-type for a Stepford Wife like existence, and worse yet – for aspiring to such.
But that’s just the tip of the iceberg. It’s not the only psychologically lethal fairy tale gem. Oh no! They are all like that. And the only differential is what story you most relate to – what one will haunt you without your knowledge and inform the more stupid choices you make – particularly with relationships. Choices you make which, in retrospect, make no sense at all.
Sleeping Beauty suggests a life of complete female passivity(to the point of being comatose) makes you a beautiful prize for a prince. Rapunzel says grow your hair long, look beautiful and unattainable (find yourself a very high tower to live in, for instance), and another prince will obviously come along. God forbid you actually do anything – exert any energy, pursue any kingdoms of your own.
I would go so far as to say that those particular three – the deadly triple threat of tales – are responsible for that terrible ‘The Bachelor’ TV series and all those women who think they fell for someone they just met, who treated them badly. And all because he was the prince on offer and all they had to prove to be was the most attractive of all. (Actually, throw Snow White in with that lot too, and all the temper tantrums in the show would probably align with the Wicked Stepmother from that tale…)
And don’t get me started on the inherent ethnic stereotype issues in these little mental health grenades…
Some others:
Jack and the Beanstalk – climb high enough and kill some monster or other and you can get rich. A good prototype for the corporate world if I’ve ever heard of one, and about as realistic!
The Child Rolande – creepy story about being abducted to the fairy world – bit like alien abduction stories, and certainly one to stir the darker and deeper recesses of the hearts of anyone unhappy in their home life. Pick me, they cry! There’s always something better, somewhere, or with someone else…..a recipe for a restless, discontented life of yearning.
For me, it was Beauty and the Beast. God help me. Looking back at my relationship choices there is a definite flavour of finding the beast and stupidly thinking caring and love would turn him into a prince. Beasts are beasts, for the most part, right through. In the end, my particular favourite fairy story really just encouraged really, really, really bad taste on my part. Hopefully I’m older and wiser now – but I still sense this weird attraction to the bad boy persona at times – old enough to just see it and not act, hopefully. But it’s the fairy story, I swear.
Heaven help me, I love a redemptive arc!
Of course, it does beg the question if the stories create our patterns or if we are drawn to the story that will best portray our own inner desires. Bit chicken and the egg really.
But I can’t help but think if I’d never heard Beauty and the Beast I might never have believed the fallacy that a true, loving heart beats behind the breastbones of men who – looking at all evidence of their natures, actions, words and so forth – have barely got a heart, let alone one that beats for anyone other than themselves.
So fairy tales should come with hazard warnings – read at your own risk. They say what we learn in childhood stays with us. Sad then that some of the most bloody and culturally suspect stories are the bed time fare for most children. Or that we love those stories so much in those early years, before we understand what we are hearing.
What about you? What was our favourite fairy tale, and do you think it tells you anything about your life and choices so far?